MomSkoop
Cape Cod’s waters deliver some of the freshest seafood on the East Coast, making it a paradise for fish lovers everywhere. Local restaurants take full advantage of this bounty, serving up everything from buttery lobster rolls to crispy fried clams. Finding the best spots can be tricky with so many options available. Here are fourteen outstanding seafood restaurants that consistently serve the freshest catch Cape Cod has to offer.
1. Seafood Sam’s, Sandwich
Family-owned since 1974, this beloved local chain started right here in Sandwich and has been perfecting their recipes for decades. Their famous fried clams come from local waters and get hand-breaded daily using a secret family recipe.
The lobster roll overflows with fresh meat, lightly dressed with mayo or served Connecticut-style with warm butter. Kids love the fish and chips, while adults rave about the seafood platters.
Casual atmosphere makes everyone feel welcome, from beach-goers to families celebrating special occasions.
2. The Brewster Fish House, Brewster
Upscale dining meets Cape Cod charm at this sophisticated restaurant that sources directly from local fishermen each morning. Chef-driven preparations showcase seasonal catches through creative preparations that highlight natural flavors rather than mask them.
The raw bar features oysters from nearby beds, while the daily specials depend entirely on what boats brought in that day. Wine pairings complement each dish perfectly.
Reservations fill up quickly during summer months, so booking ahead is essential for this culinary gem.
3. KREAM N KONE, West Dennis
This retro drive-in has been serving families since 1953, combining classic American fare with outstanding fresh seafood options. Their whole belly clams are legendary among locals who’ve been coming here for generations.
The lobster roll gets packed with generous chunks of sweet meat, while their fish and chips use fresh cod caught locally. Don’t skip the onion rings – they’re hand-cut daily.
Outdoor picnic tables and car-hop service create a nostalgic dining experience that kids absolutely love during summer visits.
4. Brax Landing Restaurant, Harwich Port
Waterfront dining doesn’t get much better than this harborside gem where fishing boats dock right outside your window. The daily catch literally comes straight from boat to kitchen, ensuring maximum freshness in every bite.
Their raw bar showcases local oysters and littlenecks, while the lobster bake includes steamers, corn, and drawn butter. The deck offers stunning water views during sunset dinners.
Live music on weekends adds to the maritime atmosphere, making this a perfect spot for romantic dinners or family celebrations.
5. The Lobster Pot, Provincetown
Provincetown’s most iconic seafood destination has been feeding hungry visitors since 1979 with generous portions and unbeatable harbor views. The building itself looks like a classic New England fishing shack, complete with weathered shingles and nautical decorations.
Their signature lobster pot pie combines fresh lobster meat with vegetables in a rich, creamy sauce topped with flaky pastry. The raw bar stays busy all day long.
Tourist crowds can mean longer waits, but the authentic atmosphere and consistently excellent food make it worthwhile every single time.
6. Lobster Trap Restaurant & Fish Market, Bourne
Smart diners know that restaurants with attached fish markets usually serve the freshest seafood, and this Bourne institution proves that rule perfectly. The market side sells directly to home cooks, while the restaurant prepares the same high-quality fish.
Their lobster bisque is rich and creamy, loaded with chunks of sweet meat. The fish market connection means daily specials feature whatever’s freshest that morning.
Casual, no-frills atmosphere focuses attention on the food rather than fancy decorations, letting the quality of ingredients speak for themselves.
7. Captain Parker’s Pub, West Yarmouth
Award-winning clam chowder put this cozy pub on the map, but their commitment to fresh local seafood keeps customers coming back year after year. The chowder has won multiple New England championships and tastes exactly like homemade.
Beyond the famous chowder, their baked stuffed lobster and fish and chips earn rave reviews from both locals and tourists. The pub atmosphere feels welcoming and comfortable.
Reasonable prices make this an excellent choice for families looking for quality seafood without breaking the budget during Cape Cod vacations.
8. Sesuit Harbor Cafe, Dennis
Hidden gem status makes this waterfront cafe a favorite among locals who want to avoid tourist crowds while enjoying exceptional fresh seafood. The small dining room overlooks the working harbor where fishing boats unload their daily catches.
Their lobster roll contains an impressive amount of meat, while the fish tacos use whatever’s freshest that day. The intimate setting creates a romantic atmosphere for couples.
Limited seating means reservations are absolutely essential, especially during peak summer months when word spreads about this special place.
9. Fishermen’s View Seafood Market & Restaurant, Sandwich
The name says it all – this combination market and restaurant sits right where fishermen bring their daily catch, guaranteeing the freshest possible seafood. Watching boats unload while you eat adds authenticity to every meal.
Their lobster rolls are generously stuffed, while the fried seafood platters showcase local scallops, clams, and fish. The market side offers take-home options for cooking enthusiasts.
Casual waterfront dining at its finest, with picnic-style tables and paper plates that let you focus on the incredible fresh flavors without any pretense.
10. Spanky’s Clam Shack and Seaside Saloon, Hyannis
Fun atmosphere and serious seafood combine at this lively waterfront spot where the party never stops during summer months. The outdoor deck overlooks Hyannis Harbor, providing entertainment as boats come and go.
Their whole belly clams are perfectly crispy outside and tender inside, while the lobster mac and cheese adds a creative twist to traditional preparations. Live music keeps energy high.
Young crowds love the bar scene, but families also enjoy the casual vibe and kid-friendly menu options that go beyond typical seafood offerings.
11. The Ocean House Restaurant, Dennis Port
Beachfront location puts diners just steps from the sand at this classic Cape Cod seafood house that’s been serving families for generations. The wraparound deck offers ocean views that make every meal feel special.
Their baked stuffed shrimp and lobster pie showcase local ingredients prepared with traditional New England techniques. The raw bar features oysters from nearby Wellfleet beds.
Sunset dinners on the deck create magical moments, especially when combined with their excellent wine selection and attentive service that makes everyone feel like regulars.
12. Moby Dick’s Restaurant, Wellfleet
Wellfleet oysters are world-famous, and this local institution serves them at their absolute peak freshness along with other outstanding seafood specialties. The rustic interior features weathered wood and maritime artifacts that create authentic seaside ambiance.
Their oyster selection changes daily based on harvest conditions, while the lobster roll contains sweet, fresh meat with minimal dressing. The clam chowder rivals any in New England.
Local fishing families have eaten here for decades, which speaks volumes about consistent quality and reasonable prices that keep the community coming back regularly.
13. Mac’s Fish House Provincetown, Provincetown
Creative preparations meet Cape Cod tradition at this chef-driven restaurant where innovative techniques highlight the natural flavors of incredibly fresh local seafood. The menu changes frequently based on daily boat arrivals.
Their crudo preparations showcase raw fish at its finest, while cooked dishes like pan-seared striped bass demonstrate technical skill. The wine list complements seafood beautifully.
Sophisticated atmosphere attracts food enthusiasts looking for elevated dining experiences that go beyond typical fried seafood while still celebrating Cape Cod’s maritime heritage and local fishing traditions.
14. The Skipper Restaurant and Chowder House, South Yarmouth
Old-school Cape Cod charm defines this family-friendly restaurant where recipes haven’t changed in decades because they were perfect from the start. The dining room feels like stepping back in time to simpler days.
Their New England clam chowder is thick, creamy, and loaded with tender clams, while the fish and chips use fresh local cod. Generous portions ensure nobody leaves hungry.
Three generations of families return year after year, creating a warm community atmosphere where servers remember regular customers and their favorite dishes from previous visits.