MomSkoop
Maine is famous for its wild blueberries, and there’s no better way to enjoy them than in a slice of fresh blueberry pie. From cozy bakeries tucked in small towns to bustling cafes in Portland, the state offers incredible spots where bakers turn local berries into mouthwatering desserts.
Whether you’re a local or just visiting, these bakeries serve up pies that will make your taste buds sing and leave you craving more.
1. Mount Dessert Bakery, Bar Harbor
Nestled in the heart of Bar Harbor, this beloved bakery has been serving locals and tourists since the early 1980s. Mount Dessert Bakery uses wild Maine blueberries picked at their peak, creating pies with a perfect balance of sweet and tart flavors.
The flaky, buttery crust practically melts in your mouth, while the generous blueberry filling bursts with authentic berry goodness. Grab a slice with your morning coffee or take a whole pie back to your vacation rental.
Their dedication to traditional baking methods means every pie tastes like it came straight from grandma’s kitchen.
2. Puzzle Mountain Bakery, Newry
Puzzle Mountain Bakery in Newry feels like discovering a hidden Maine treasure.
Their famous blueberry pie stands out with its rustic lattice crust and perfectly balanced filling made from local berries. Each slice highlights the bakery’s commitment to old-fashioned techniques and simple, honest ingredients.
Whether you’re stopping by after a hike or exploring the peaceful countryside, this bakery offers a comforting taste of Maine tradition.
3. Two Fat Cats Bakery, Portland
With a quirky name and serious baking skills, Two Fat Cats has become a Portland institution since opening its doors. Their blueberry pie features a golden crust that’s both beautiful and delicious, showcasing the baker’s attention to detail.
Inside, you’ll find plump Maine blueberries swimming in a slightly thickened sauce that’s neither too runny nor too gummy. The balance is absolutely spot-on.
Lines often form out the door on weekends, so arriving early is smart. Trust us, one bite explains why locals consider this place a must-visit destination for pie lovers.
4. Hello Good Pie, Belgrade Lakes
Ever dreamed of enjoying pie while overlooking peaceful Maine lakes? Hello Good Pie makes that dream a reality with their lakeside location and exceptional baking. Their name says it all—this place knows how to create memorable pies.
Using locally sourced wild blueberries, they craft pies that taste like summer in every forkful. The crust strikes that rare balance between tender and crispy, holding together beautifully without being tough.
Many customers say it reminds them of pies their mothers used to bake, which is the highest compliment any baker can receive.
5. Auntie’s House Bakery and Chocolatier, Kennebunk
Stepping into Auntie’s House feels like visiting a relative who happens to be an amazing baker and chocolatier. This Kennebunk gem combines European baking techniques with classic Maine ingredients, resulting in pies that taste both familiar and refined.
Their blueberry pie showcases a hint of lemon zest that brightens the filling without overpowering the berries. The crust, made with real butter, adds richness that elevates each bite.
Did you know Maine produces 99% of America’s wild blueberries? Auntie’s House celebrates this fact with pride in every slice they serve.
6. Tandem Coffee and Bakery, Portland
Coffee lovers and pie enthusiasts unite at Tandem, where expertly roasted coffee meets outstanding baked goods. While many come for the beverages, their blueberry pie has quietly become one of Portland’s best-kept secrets among dessert fans.
The bakers here aren’t afraid to experiment, sometimes adding a touch of cardamom or vanilla to complement the blueberries’ natural tartness. Fresh, never frozen berries ensure maximum flavor in every slice.
Pair your pie with their signature cold brew for an afternoon treat that hits all the right notes.
7. Sweet Cheeks Bakery, Verona Island
Located on picturesque Verona Island, Sweet Cheeks brings playful charm and serious baking talent to Maine’s midcoast region. This bakery has earned a loyal following thanks to generous portions and pies that taste like pure comfort.
Their blueberry pie comes loaded with fruit—no skimpy fillings here! The bottom crust stays wonderfully crisp even under all those juicy berries, which shows real baking expertise.
Local fishermen and summer visitors alike stop by for a slice, creating a welcoming community atmosphere. It’s the kind of place where strangers become friends over shared pie appreciation.
8. The Cookie Jar, Cape Elizabeth
Don’t let the name fool you—The Cookie Jar bakes phenomenal pies that rival their famous cookies. This Cape Elizabeth favorite has been delighting customers for decades with recipes passed down through generations of bakers.
Their blueberry pie features a double crust that’s perfectly golden and flaky, encasing a filling made with just the right amount of sugar to let the berries shine. Nothing fancy, just honest, delicious baking done right.
Many families make stopping here a tradition during their Maine vacations, creating sweet memories one slice at a time.