MomSkoop
New York City may be the celebrated hub of pizza perfection, but venture beyond the towering skyline, and you’ll discover small towns in New York State where the pizza is a slice above the rest. Locals in these quaint towns fiercely defend their culinary creations, claiming their pies surpass those of the big city.
From wood-fired masterpieces in Rhinebeck to inventive delights in Beacon, each town offers a unique take on the classic slice. Whether you’re a pizza purist or an adventurous eater, these small towns promise an unforgettable pizza experience that might just make you rethink New York’s pizza supremacy.
1. Rhinebeck (Hudson Valley)
Pizzeria Posto in Rhinebeck is famed for its wood-fired artisan pies. Imagine biting into a crust that’s crisp on the outside yet fluffy inside—a textural delight. Reviews often rave about the unparalleled flavor. “Some of the best I’ve had anywhere in the world,” one diner exclaimed.
Locals in Rhinebeck are proud of their pizza heritage. Nestled in the Hudson Valley, they argue their pizza beats many city establishments. The use of fresh ingredients and traditional methods make each pie a masterpiece.
This small town offers a unique pizza experience, drawing food lovers from all over. The combination of rustic charm and exceptional pizza makes Rhinebeck a must-visit.
2. High Falls (Hudson Valley)
High Falls might be a small village, but its pizza scene packs a flavorful punch. Ollie’s Pizza is at the forefront, captivating taste buds with wood-fired pies that defy expectations. With every bite, you’ll discover a balance of smoky crust and savory toppings.
Locals proudly assert their town’s culinary prowess. “Small town, big flavor,” they say. The warm and welcoming atmosphere of High Falls makes it a delightful stop for pizza enthusiasts.
Visitors often find themselves surprised by the quality and creativity of the offerings here. It’s a slice of paradise nestled quietly in the Hudson Valley, waiting to be discovered.
3. Montgomery (Orange County / Hudson Valley)
In the heart of Montgomery, Cascarino’s Pizzeria stands as a testament to family-run dedication. Awarded “Best Pizza in the Hudson Valley” in 2025, this spot is all about quality. Each pizza is crafted with care, using local ingredients to ensure exceptional flavor.
The pizzeria’s reputation is built on its ability to challenge big city chains. “Our pizza fights with the big city,” locals proclaim, celebrating their unique culinary flair. Montgomery offers more than just delicious slices—it provides a true taste of community.
Here, the emphasis is on tradition and innovation, blending them seamlessly for an unforgettable dining experience.
4. Poughkeepsie (Dutchess County)
Poughkeepsie is a hidden gem in the world of pizza, ranked #6 among New York State’s pizza cities. This honor speaks volumes about its vibrant pizza culture, bursting with independent spots offering diverse flavors and styles.
Locals boast about the variety and creativity found in their town. “We’ve got more great independent spots per capita,” they proudly declare. In Poughkeepsie, pizza is more than a meal—it’s an experience.
The community’s passion for pizza is evident in every corner, where each slice tells a story of dedication and love for this iconic dish. Poughkeepsie is a true pizza paradise.
5. Kingston (Ulster County)
Kingston’s pizza scene is as vibrant as its community. The town boasts multiple renowned spots, including Lola Pizza, where each pie is crafted with meticulous attention to detail. Wood-fired joints add to the rich tapestry of flavors found here.
Residents claim their pizzas rival even the best city offerings. “We can rival the city—maybe even beat it,” they assert with pride. Kingston is where tradition meets creativity, and each pizza embodies this fusion.
The town’s dedication to top-quality ingredients and innovative techniques makes it a must-visit for pizza lovers. Kingston is truly a slice above.
6. Troy (Rensselaer County)
Dante’s Pizzeria in Troy is legendary among locals, celebrated for its incredible pizzas. It’s a spot where pizza dreams come to life, creating dishes that locals swear are the best in the state.
“If you’re going to call yourself a pizza lover, you’ll come here,” they challenge, inviting enthusiasts to taste for themselves. Troy’s pizza scene is rich with history and flavor, making it a destination worth exploring.
Each pizza at Dante’s is a testament to the town’s commitment to culinary excellence. From classic combinations to innovative toppings, Troy offers a pizza experience that rivals any big city.
7. Pearl River (Rockland County)
Pearl River may be known as a commuter town, but its pizza culture is anything but ordinary. Standout pies, like the eggplant supreme, have earned this town a spot on must-try lists.
Residents proudly proclaim their slice culture as full-blown, enticing visitors to explore diverse and delicious offerings. The creativity in Pearl River’s pizzerias is unmatched, providing flavors that surprise and delight.
This small town’s dedication to quality and innovation in pizza-making makes it a hidden gem. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Pearl River promises a memorable pizza experience.
8. Fishkill (Dutchess County)
In Fishkill, pizza lovers find joy in unique pies and late-night slices that hit all the right notes. The town is frequently mentioned in pizza round-ups for its standout offerings.
Locals assert their dominance in flavor, claiming city folk are often surprised by the culinary prowess found here. “Our flavor hits different,” they say, inviting pizza enthusiasts to taste the difference.
Fishkill’s pizza scene is a delightful blend of creativity and tradition, offering flavors that linger long after the last bite. Whether it’s a classic slice or something more adventurous, Fishkill delivers.
9. Beacon (Dutchess County)
Beacon is a small town with big pizza dreams, offering top-tier spots known for inventive toppings and offerings. It’s a place where culinary creativity thrives, surprising even the most seasoned pizza aficionados.
Locals boast of making “city pizza jealous,” with slices that are both innovative and delicious. Beacon’s pizzerias are a testament to the town’s commitment to quality and creativity.
From the traditional to the unconventional, Beacon’s pizza scene offers something for everyone. It’s a town where each bite is a new adventure, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers.
10. Millbrook (Dutchess County)
In Millbrook, wood-fired Italian-style pizzas elevate the town’s culinary scene. Known for its upscale yet rural charm, Millbrook offers a pizza experience that stands out.
Locals proudly declare their pies punch above their weight. “Our pizza compares to any city slice,” they assert, highlighting the dedication to crafting exceptional pizzas.
The combination of fresh ingredients and traditional techniques ensures every pie is a masterpiece. Millbrook’s pizzerias are a hidden treasure, offering flavors that make the journey worthwhile. It’s an elevated experience that captures the heart and taste buds.