MomSkoop
Ever wonder what beauty trends might not be landing quite as well as you thought? While women should always feel free to express themselves however they like, it turns out some popular makeup and style choices don’t get the thumbs up from everyone. We asked men to share their honest opinions about current beauty trends, and their answers might surprise you.
1. Overly Drawn-On Eyebrows
Bold brows have been all the rage for years, but many guys admit they prefer something more natural-looking.
When eyebrows are drawn on too heavily or look like thick blocks of color, it can seem artificial rather than attractive.
The goal of great eyebrows should be to frame your face beautifully without screaming for attention.
Soft, feathered strokes that mimic real hair tend to look much more flattering than harsh, overly defined lines.
Most men appreciate when eyebrows enhance your features without becoming the main focal point of your entire face.
A lighter hand with the brow pencil can make all the difference in achieving a more approachable and genuine appearance.
2. Duck Face Selfies
Remember when everyone started puckering their lips for photos?
That duck face pose became incredibly popular on social media, but guys consistently say it looks forced and silly.
A genuine smile or relaxed expression tends to be far more appealing than contorted lips.
The duck face can make someone appear insecure or like they’re trying too hard to look cute.
Natural expressions showcase personality and warmth, which most people find much more attractive than any posed look.
Confidence shines through when you’re comfortable being yourself rather than mimicking trends that feel awkward and overdone to many viewers.
3. Extremely Long Fake Nails
Stiletto nails and super-long acrylics might look impressive, but they leave many men scratching their heads.
Practical concerns come up immediately—how do you text, type, or handle everyday tasks with claws that long?
Beyond functionality, extremely lengthy nails can appear intimidating rather than elegant.
Many guys prefer shorter, well-maintained nails that look polished without being impractical.
Nail art can be fun and creative, but when nails become so long they seem uncomfortable, the appeal fades quickly.
A classic manicure with reasonable length tends to win out over dramatic talons that dominate your hands completely.
4. Heavy Contouring
Contouring became a massive trend thanks to beauty influencers and celebrities, but not everyone’s a fan.
When done too heavily, it can look like stripes painted across your face rather than subtle shadows.
The idea behind contouring is to enhance your bone structure, but overdoing it creates an artificial, mask-like appearance.
Men often say they prefer seeing someone’s actual face rather than layers of sculpting makeup.
Light contouring can definitely enhance features beautifully, but extreme versions tend to backfire.
Your natural face shape is usually more attractive than trying to dramatically alter it with dark and light powders every single day.
5. Overfilled Lips
Plump lips are considered beautiful, but there’s definitely such a thing as too much filler.
When lips look swollen, unnatural, or disproportionate to the rest of someone’s face, it becomes distracting.
Many men admit they find overfilled lips concerning rather than attractive, wondering why natural beauty wasn’t enough.
Subtle enhancement can look great, but obvious work tends to have the opposite effect than intended.
Lips that look painful or inflated make people uncomfortable rather than impressed.
Balance is key—proportions matter more than simply making features bigger, and natural-looking results always age better than extreme modifications that scream artificial.
6. Fake Eyelashes That Are Too Dramatic
Fluttery lashes can definitely enhance your eyes, but some falsies cross the line into costume territory.
When eyelashes are so long and thick they look like spiders or feathers, they become the only thing people notice.
Eyes are beautiful on their own, and lashes should complement them rather than overwhelm everything else.
Many guys say they can’t even focus on someone’s actual eyes when the lashes are ridiculously exaggerated.
Natural-looking lash extensions or subtle falsies tend to be much more appealing than theatrical versions.
Your eyes should draw people in with their color and expression, not distract them with artificial fringe that seems heavy and uncomfortable.
7. Overlined Lips
Trying to make lips appear fuller by drawing outside the natural line has become common practice.
Unfortunately, this technique rarely fools anyone and often looks messy or clownish instead.
The visible outline beyond your actual lips creates an awkward border that draws attention for all the wrong reasons.
Most men say they’d rather see someone’s real lip shape than an obviously fake attempt at enlargement.
Overlining might photograph well with certain filters, but in person it usually just looks like a makeup mistake.
Embracing your natural lip shape and using techniques that enhance rather than alter tends to create much more attractive and believable results overall.
8. Excessive Highlighter
A subtle glow can make skin look healthy and radiant, but too much highlighter creates a different effect entirely.
When your face looks like a disco ball or appears greasy from across the room, the highlighter has defeated its purpose.
Men often mention that excessive shimmer seems more distracting than beautiful, making them wonder if someone’s just really sweaty.
The goal should be a natural-looking luminosity, not a blinding reflection.
Strategic placement of a small amount works wonders, while coating every high point creates an artificial, overdone appearance.
Skin that looks naturally healthy beats overly sparkly makeup any day, especially in normal lighting where extreme highlighter can appear truly bizarre.
9. Visible Lip Liner Without Lipstick
Back in the day, dark lip liner with nude or bare lips was everywhere.
This look has made comebacks periodically, but men consistently rank it as one of their least favorite trends.
The harsh outline creates an unfinished appearance that seems more like someone forgot to complete their makeup.
Lips end up looking smaller and drawn-on rather than naturally defined and full.
Most guys prefer either a natural bare lip or a complete lipstick look rather than this in-between style.
If you love liner, blending it properly with your lipstick creates a much more polished and attractive finish than leaving stark, visible lines around your mouth.
10. Overly Bronzed or Orange Skin
Sun-kissed skin looks gorgeous, but there’s a fine line between golden glow and traffic cone orange.
Self-tanners and bronzers gone wrong create an unmistakably artificial appearance that men consistently find unappealing.
When your face is several shades darker than your neck, or your skin has an orange tint, something’s clearly off.
Natural skin tones in any shade are beautiful and don’t need to be drastically altered.
Most guys appreciate when someone embraces their actual complexion rather than trying to fake a different one.
If you love bronzer or self-tanner, applying it lightly and choosing the right shade makes all the difference between healthy radiance and obvious fakery.