MomSkoop
In New York, the Friday fish fry isn’t just a menu special — it’s a cherished tradition. Rooted in Catholic customs and embraced by communities across the state, fish fries bring neighbors together over crispy golden haddock, hearty sides, and hometown hospitality. From cozy diners to old-school taverns, here are six classic New York Friday fish fries that keep locals coming back week after week.
1. Gene McCarthy’s – Buffalo
At Gene McCarthy’s, you get two Buffalo staples in one spot: craft beer and an unforgettable fish fry. This family-friendly pub is famous for pairing its crispy haddock with fresh pours from Old First Ward Brewing, creating a combination that has locals hooked. The setting is warm and inviting, with a neighborhood vibe that makes everyone feel welcome. The fish portions are generous, the batter is light and crisp, and the experience is about more than just food — it’s about sharing a meal in one of Buffalo’s most beloved watering holes.
2. McPartlan’s Corner – Buffalo
Established in 1955, this family-run gem is tucked in Cheektowaga but still feels small-town authentic. Locals line up for their famous fish fry, which features flaky haddock, crispy breading, and sides like potato salad, coleslaw, and fries. There’s usually a wait, but worth it—the kind of place where the PA system chants your name when your table’s ready, and everyone treats the staff like an old friend.
3. The Fish Friar – Syracuse
In downtown Syracuse, The Fish Friar brings an elevated twist to the daily fish fry. Here, seafood is sustainably sourced (often from Maine), served fresh, and prepared just right—crispy on the outside, tender inside. While the ambiance is more refined than dive bars, the love of the fish fry tradition runs just as deep. It’s a favorite for those who want great fish with a polished dining atmosphere.
4. Rudy’s Lakeside Drive-In – Oswego
A summer icon perched along Lake Ontario—Rudy’s serves fried seafood from a no-frills drive-in with picnic tables and lake views. Burrito enthusiasts and seafood lovers alike make the pilgrimage for their fried fish plates, burgers, and a nostalgic vibe that screams “classic lakeside summer.” Perfect for when the weather’s fine and the call of the shore is strong.
5. Witter’s Sports Bar & Grill – North Tonawanda
Want your fish fry with a healthy side of wings and sports on TV? Witter’s delivers. Known for a beer-battered, breaded, or broiled fish fry served with lazy pierogis, fries, German potato salad, and coleslaw—Witter’s is casual, local, and hearty. It’s a great stop for families or friends looking for a relaxed vibe and satisfying comfort food in North Tonawanda.
6. Penn Yan Diner – Penn Yan
This retro diner has old-school charm written all over it, with its dining-car style and open-all-day breakfast. While it’s best known for breakfast and classic diner fare, it temporarily closed due to a fire but reopened with many of the beloved menu items and staff retained—keeping local tradition alive as they rebuild. If and when their fish fry is back in rotation, it’s sure to be just as classic as the diner itself.
(Note: As of latest reports, the structure is being reconstructed.)