MomSkoop
Frozen dinners have come a long way from the bland TV trays of the past — but which ones are actually worth buying? To find out, I taste-tested seven popular frozen dinners, from comfort classics to trendy healthy options. Some were forgettable, others better than expected, but two completely caught me off guard in the best way. Here’s what I discovered when I compared them side by side — and which frozen meals are actually worth keeping in your freezer.
1. Healthy Choice Simply Steamers Grilled Chicken Pesto & Vegetables
With a delightful aroma of basil and garlic, the Healthy Choice Grilled Chicken Pesto & Vegetables is a feast for the senses. The grilled chicken is tender, perfectly complemented by a light pesto sauce.
This dish boasts a balanced mix of protein and veggies, making it both nutritious and flavorful. Its short ingredient list is a testament to quality, avoiding unnecessary additives. It’s a solid choice for those seeking a health-conscious meal that doesn’t compromise on taste.
The real surprise? How quickly it transports you to a gourmet dining experience with minimal effort.
2. Trader Joe’s Chicken Tikka Masala
If you’re craving Indian cuisine, Trader Joe’s Chicken Tikka Masala is a delightful option. The rich, creamy sauce envelops tender pieces of chicken, providing an authentic taste of Indian flavors.
The basmati rice, though slightly sticky, complements the meal well. For a frozen dinner, it successfully replicates the spices and aromas one might expect from a restaurant dish. Its surprising authenticity and depth of flavor bring an unexpected delight.
This meal is a standout for anyone seeking a quick, yet flavorful, cultural culinary experience at home.
3. Evol Fire Grilled Steak
Evol Fire Grilled Steak offers a robust, savory experience. The steak slices are smoky and tender, paired with a flavorful mix of black beans, rice, bell peppers, and corn. This meal is high in protein and fiber, making it a satisfying choice.
It’s perfect for those seeking a hearty dinner without leaving home. While the portion might seem small, the richness of flavors compensates generously.
The unexpected depth of the grilled steak’s flavor surprised me, challenging the stereotype of bland frozen dinners.
4. Hungry-Man Smokin’ Backyard Barbeque
Hungry-Man Smokin’ Backyard Barbeque promises a generous serving, but the reality falls short. The processed meats lack the desired smokiness, while the sides fail to impress.
Despite its hearty appearance, this meal doesn’t deliver on flavor. The mashed potatoes are bland, and the ribs are disappointingly chewy. It’s a reminder that more isn’t always better.
The surprise here was the disparity between its enticing packaging and underwhelming taste. For those seeking a true BBQ experience, this might not satisfy the craving.
5. Stouffer’s Salisbury Steak
Stouffer’s Salisbury Steak aims to offer comfort, but misses the mark. The gravy is overly thick, and the steak lacks the promised juiciness. Mashed potatoes add little to the overall experience, feeling more like a filler.
It’s an option for those nostalgic for TV dinners of the past, but not for those seeking fresh flavors. The biggest surprise is how it clings to outdated expectations rather than embracing modern culinary trends. Its struggle to balance classic and contemporary leaves it lacking in finesse.
6. Amy’s Light & Lean Quinoa & Black Bean
Amy’s Light & Lean Quinoa & Black Bean is a nutritional powerhouse with a surprising burst of flavor. The combination of quinoa and black beans delivers a satisfying, earthy taste, punctuated by sweet corn.
It’s a refreshing choice for those mindful of calorie intake without sacrificing taste. The light sauce ties the ingredients together beautifully.
The real surprise? Its ability to offer a fulfilling meal that feels both light and indulgent. This dish stands out for its clever balancing of health and flavor.
7. Marie Callender’s Chicken Pot Pie
Marie Callender’s Chicken Pot Pie evokes nostalgia with its flaky crust and creamy filling. Each bite is a comforting embrace of tender chicken, peas, and carrots, reminiscent of homemade meals.
The rich sauce enhances the experience, making it a heartwarming dinner choice. While it provides a classic taste, the surprise lies in the crust’s quality, retaining a delightful crispiness even from the microwave.
This pot pie is a comforting throwback to simpler times, perfect for those seeking a cozy night in.