MomSkoop
Florida, with its rich culinary heritage, is a paradise for pie lovers seeking the nostalgic taste of homemade goodness. From the tangy zest of Key lime to the comforting warmth of apple, the Sunshine State offers a delightful array of pies that evoke memories of Grandma’s kitchen.
Whether you’re a resident or a visitor, these pie shops capture the essence of homemade flavors with their meticulously crafted offerings. Indulge in towering meringues, creamy fillings, and freshly baked crusts as you explore these establishments that bring a slice of homemade heaven to Florida’s diverse landscape. Here’s where to find the best homemade pies in Florida, just like Grandma used to make.
1. Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop (Miami)
In the heart of Miami, Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop is a local treasure for pie enthusiasts. Known for its generous portions and rich flavors, this shop offers pies loaded with fresh ingredients, ensuring every bite is memorable. The journey from Miami’s vibrant streets to the cozy interior is a treat in itself.
Founded by a former firefighter, the shop reflects a spirited Miami vibe. Each pie is crafted with care, drawing lines of eager customers who often can’t resist taking their slice to nearby beaches. With a reputation for selling out quickly, it’s a place where you taste dedication and passion in every bite.
2. Sister Honey’s Bakery (Orlando)
Sister Honey’s Bakery in Orlando brings a touch of southern warmth with its time-tested pie recipes. This bakery exudes a familial atmosphere, reminiscent of a loving grandmother’s kitchen, offering comforting pies that soothe the soul. The pies here are a testament to culinary craftsmanship.
Known for their Southern-style decadence, these pies are made with love and tradition. The aroma of freshly baked goods fills the air, inviting you in for a taste of nostalgia. It’s a place where each pie tells a story, and every visit feels like coming home.
3. Yoder’s Amish Village Bakery (Sarasota)
At Yoder’s Amish Village Bakery, simplicity and tradition blend to create pies that are cherished by Sarasota locals. Their towering apple pies and classic shoofly pie are a celebration of old-fashioned baking, proving that sometimes the simplest things are the most delightful.
With its roots in Amish tradition, the bakery focuses on quality and authenticity. The warm, welcoming atmosphere invites you to slow down and savor the taste of time-honored recipes. It’s a place where pies are more than just desserts; they’re a return to simplicity and genuine flavors.
4. Mixed Fillings Pie Shop (Jacksonville)
In Jacksonville, Mixed Fillings Pie Shop delights with its adventurous approach to traditional pies. This bakery is a haven for the bold and curious, offering innovative flavors that still manage to capture the comforting essence of home-baked treats.
The shop’s playful atmosphere encourages creativity, evident in every slice. With a menu that changes seasonally, each visit promises a new experience. Despite their modern twist, these pies retain a familiar warmth, inviting both locals and visitors to indulge in a bit of culinary exploration.
5. Wright’s Gourmet House (Tampa)
Wright’s Gourmet House has been a beloved part of Tampa since the 1960s, offering pies that are rich with nostalgia and flavor. This shop is a testament to enduring quality, serving classic pies like chocolate peanut butter and Key lime that transport you back in time.
The quaint, old-world charm of the bakery creates an inviting space where stories of the past meet the present. With each slice, you’re treated to a piece of history, lovingly crafted and packed with tradition. It’s a taste of Tampa’s culinary heritage.
6. Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe (Atlantic Beach)
Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe in Atlantic Beach is a sugary dream come to life. This cozy spot is renowned for its towering cream pies and golden meringues, offering a slice of heaven that feels straight out of a fairy tale.
The beachside location adds to the allure, providing the perfect setting to enjoy these delightful treats. Each pie is crafted with precision, ensuring that every bite is a testament to the bakery’s dedication to quality. It’s a sweet escape, perfect for those who appreciate the finer things in life.
7. Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory (Tavernier)
Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory offers a taste of the Keys in every tangy, refreshing slice. Located in Tavernier, this pie factory is as vibrant as its name, drawing visitors in with its lively island feel and famously tangy Key lime pies.
The pies here are a refreshing delight, perfectly capturing the essence of the Florida Keys. With a loyal fanbase and a reputation for quality, Blond Giraffe remains a must-visit for anyone seeking a true taste of island life.
8. The Florida Key Lime Pie Company (Cocoa Beach)
The Florida Key Lime Pie Company in Cocoa Beach is synonymous with vacation indulgence. Their perfectly balanced Key lime pies offer a tart-sweet experience that can’t be missed, making this a beachfront favorite.
The shop captures the laid-back vibe of Cocoa Beach with its vibrant decor and inviting atmosphere. Beachgoers flock here to enjoy a slice, finding the experience as refreshing as a day on the waves. It’s a place where the pie captures the spirit of Florida’s coastal charm.